Home Quizzes Current Affairs Mains PYQs Saved Items
UPPSC
GS-2 • 2022
15 marks • 250 words

GS-2 • 2022

Back
15 Marks • 250 Words
Are the committees considered to be useful for Parliamentary work? Discuss, in this context, the role of the Estimates Committee.
Attempt This PYQ
Write a timed answer first, then compare with model framework below.
Syllabus: Structure, functioning and conduct of business. 15 marks 250 words 7 min focus timer
Timer: 07:00
Model Answer Framework
English Model Answer
EN
Introduction

1 Introduction

In a modern parliamentary democracy, the volume and complexity of legislative, financial and administrative work are too large to be handled effectively by the entire House alone. Therefore, Parliamentary Committees are regarded as indispensable instruments of Parliament.

They enable detailed examination, informed discussion and effective control over the executive. In this context, the Estimates Committee plays an important role by examining budget estimates and suggesting economy, efficiency and administrative improvement in public expenditure.

Body: Usefulness of Committees and the Role of the Estimates Committee

Flow Chart: Why Committees are Useful

Parliamentary Committees

Detailed Scrutiny

Clause-by-clause
subject-wise
careful examination

Expert Work

Better study
evidence-based review
informed recommendations

Executive Control

Accountability
financial discipline
policy follow-up

Efficiency

Saves House time
reduces overload
improves output

Outcome: More informed legislation, stronger accountability and better parliamentary control. 

1. Why Committees are Useful for Parliamentary Work

  • They reduce the workload of Parliament: Since the House has limited time, committees examine matters in detail and present focused reports.

  • They ensure detailed scrutiny: Bills, budgets, policies and administrative actions can be examined more carefully than is possible in full House debates.

  • They improve quality of discussion: Committee work is usually less partisan and more analytical, leading to balanced recommendations.

  • They strengthen executive accountability: Ministers and departments are subjected to closer examination, especially in financial and administrative matters.

  • They promote efficiency: Committees help Parliament function more systematically and effectively.

2. The Estimates Committee: Composition and Nature

The Estimates Committee is one of the major Financial Committees of Parliament. It consists of 30 members, all elected from the Lok Sabha every year according to the principle of proportional representation by means of the single transferable vote. A minister cannot be a member of this committee.

Its function is not merely to check figures, but to examine how public money may be spent more wisely, economically and efficiently.

3. Role of the Estimates Committee

  • Examines budget estimates: It studies the estimates included in the budget and selects specific ministries or departments for detailed review.

  • Suggests economy in expenditure: It recommends ways to reduce wasteful or unnecessary expenditure.

  • Improves administrative efficiency: It suggests reforms in organisation, procedure and management for better functioning of departments.

  • Recommends alternative policies: It may propose better methods for achieving the objectives of a programme at lower cost or with better results.

  • Ensures financial prudence: It helps Parliament maintain control over public expenditure even after the budget is voted.

4. Significance and Limitation

The Estimates Committee is important because it goes beyond routine financial approval and focuses on economy, efficiency and improvement. In this sense, it is an instrument of constructive financial control.

However, its role is advisory. It cannot directly enforce its recommendations, and it does not examine accounts in the same way as the Public Accounts Committee. Yet, its reports often guide better governance and prudent expenditure.

Conclusion

Thus, Parliamentary Committees are extremely useful for effective parliamentary functioning. They make Parliament more informed, efficient and accountable.

In this framework, the Estimates Committee plays a vital role by examining budget estimates and recommending economy, efficiency and improvement in public administration. It is, therefore, an important instrument of financial oversight and responsible governance.

Core Idea: Committees make Parliament effective; the Estimates Committee makes public expenditure economical, efficient and accountable.

Conclusion

 

Syllabus Anchoring
General Studies II → Parliament and State Legislatures
सामान्य अध्ययन - 2 → संसद और राज्य विधायिकाएं
Structure, functioning and conduct of business.
संरचना, कार्यप्रणाली और कार्य संचालन।
Asked in: 2022 (1 PYQ)
Related Current Affairs
No current-affairs links yet.